Jesus people, loving people

Hope or hype?

A look at the charismatic conservatism of Johann Blumhardt

Two common features of today’s charismatic Christianity are a tendency to hype and triumphalism and a shift of focus from Church to the individual. What is so significant about German theologian Johann Christoph Blumhardt, is that he deliberately refused both of these. Following a much-publicised exorcism, with the whole neighbourhood paying attention, he took deliberate steps to dampen any thrill-seeking tendencies. He refused anything that smacked of sensationalism.

Christoph Blumhardt

Blumhardt was also conservative in his ecclesiology: he firmly believed in the established church. He was familiar with developments across the channel in England, which by this time had seen the Quakers, then the Great Awakening, the powerful moving of God associated with the Wesleys and George Whitefield. These times of the in-breaking of God’s power had led to large numbers leaving the Anglican Communion to found new groups and movements.

By contrast, Germany had always been resistant to sectarianism, but in Blumhardt, the message of renewal and the manifest power of God with signs and wonders came from a solid son of the church who had no intention of seceding from it. This resonated far and wide, and Blumhardt’s parsonage welcomed thousands of visitors, including author/parson Eduard Mörike and novelist Hermann Hesse.

A number recorded their reactions.

1. FAITH. “He really does believe! It isn’t magic!”, wrote Blumhardt’s bishop. Real faith, “the faith that pulls the fire from heaven” (Salvation Army hymn) has always fascinated and attracted. People want to believe in the miraculous. Blumhardt made it seem quite ordinary.

2. HOPE. Blumhardt’s heightened understanding of light and darkness (through the exorcism of 1842) made him see that God was ready at any moment to invade the darkness of human life with the light that is the real Jesus – not of “religion” but of life . Darkness, he wrote, is contrary to our nature if we are of God, so there will always be a way to escape from it if we put our trust in Him.

3. LOVE. “Love is his religion”, wrote a noted painter. Blumhardt’s God was compassionate, offered hope, gave repentance and a new start even to the most damaged and dirty, and any manifestation of healing or the miraculous was a signpost to that nature in Him. This too is timelessly attractive, especially to Christians stultified by habit – what Blumhardt called “religion”.

All of these, Blumhardt believed, were available within the orbit of the church. But because of much encrusting of habitual “church-ianity”, God’s lavish heart in these areas had to be actively preached, which is what Blumhardt gave himself to doing – while resisting any temptation to cast the church aside in favour of ‘freer’, individual spirituality.


This was a repost from a blog written by Trevor Saxby’s post Hope or Hype? The Charismatic Conservatism of Johann Blumhardt

Published 10th November 2017 with tags: faith

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WordPress Lightbox